What makes Bruster's special?

Brusters ensures that everything is fresh and of the highest quality at every step of the process. This means all toppings are sustainably sourced, all fruit is fresh, produce is delivered regularly, and most importantly - they own their own dairy. This means they not only cut costs on the milk and cream that they bring in but they can guarantee freshness and quality from cow to cone. All Bruster's ice cream is created in small artisan batches made the traditional way. And, it is done so in store. Meaning every time you go to Bruster's for a scoop of ice cream it is rich, creamy, fresh, and totally delicious. It takes a lot of love and devotion to go the extra mile and be so involved in every step of the process. But, that's what Bruce Reed envisioned for his company so that's what happens. The quality and attention to detail that made his first store so successful is what has, and will continue to, drive his franchise forward.

What does small-batch ice cream mean?

When it comes to producing ice cream, or most products mind you, there are two major choices. Mass/large production or small batch. When Brusters talk about their small batch production it simply means that each flavor is made on the spot as and when it's needed. Huge quantities are not frozen and stored for later. No, when a flavor runs out it is replaced by a new one and then someone will make a fresh batch of whatever is needed. It is part of the reason Brusters have so many rotating flavors. When it comes to ice cream small batch production is the only way to guarantee freshness and quality every time. The difference between ice cream made weeks ago and ice cream made this morning is night and day. Brusters wants to produce the best ice cream, so why would you settle for any less? Small-batch artisan ice cream is what made them famous.

Does Bruster's offer dairy-free ice creams?

Yes! Brusters has plenty of amazing dairy-free ice cream choices for you. It isn't uncommon for ice cream joints to have sorbets and Bruster's is no different. They have a constant rotation of excellent sorbets and iced drinks for you to choose from with alternating flavors and a consistent feeling of freshness. Where Bruisers goes one step further by creating delicious, rich, creamy, and so inviting dairy-free oat-milk-based ice cream for you to try. Whether you are veggie, vegan, dairy-free, or simply prefer oat milk - their amazing oat milk ice cream is just what the doctor ordered on a hot sunny day.

What are the most popular menu items?

The menu at Bruster's changes so drastically from store to store, even from day to day, so it is hard to pin down absolute favorites. Their ice cream is obviously their heart and soul and that's why most people love Brusters so much. When it comes to specific flavors, it depends. Brusters has so many amazing season flavors that it's almost impossible to choose a favorite. If you are enthralled with fall, then pumpkin pie may be your go-to. If you are a summer supporter, perhaps the classic vanilla is just what you need. The possibilities are endless, the flavors are boundless, and Brusters never fails to deliver on quality and taste. Even after 30-plus years.

Approximately 2 minutes reading time — Ice Cream

Brusters menu prices featuring 19 items ranging from $2.82 to $11.00

Q: Is Bruster's ice cream healthy?

We don't go to an ice cream restaurant to be healthy. Do we? Probably not, but that doesn't mean that ice cream has to be necessarily bad for you. As ice cream goes, Bruster's is on the healthier side as it is lower in sugar and only the freshest ingredients are used. Since it does not need to be stored and transported it is free from additives, preservatives, and other unnatural stabilizers. Since you have total control over toppings and flavors, how healthy your particular ice cream is will largely be in your own hands. Fresh fruit and a nice sorbet are going to be a little healthier than chocolate ice cream with chocolate sprinkles, won't they? But, we don't have to be healthy every day. Ice cream is meant to be a treat, sometimes we <s>want </s>need a little more chocolate in our life. Even vegan chocolate.

If you are someone who enjoys homemade ice cream, which let's face it, we all do - then a trip to Brusters may be on the menu! Brusters has 24 unique flavors of ice cream on the menu at any one time and is constantly rotating them out for one of the over 150 delicious homemade recipes they have in their arsenal to keep things fresh and interesting. Bruster's has managed to stay in the game so long due to the huge array of other tasty treats they have created to accompany their iconic ice cream: pies, cakes, pastries, splits, milkshakes - you want it, they got it. Their famous Bruster's Blasts allow you to mix and match to your heart's desire creating an unprecedented amount of combos to suit your unique taste buds!

Written by Justine Marie Abrio

Published at Friday, September 30, 2022

Page Reviewed by Matt Hodson

Last Review Date: 12/01/2024

Next Review Date: 01/01/2025

Justine Marie Abrio personally visited Brusters and dedicated 1 hours 18 minutes researching the Brusters menu and prices.

Brusters menu prices featuring 19 items ranging from $2.82 to $11.00

Brusters Menu
Why Bruster's steals the show?
Power of small-batch ice cream?
Does Bruster's cater to dairy-free preferences?
Is Bruster's ice cream healthy?
So, what's hot on the menu?

When I step into Bruster's, which is open every day from 11 am to 10 pm, it's like stepping into a dreamland of creamy delights. The tantalizing options go beyond just ice cream - they've got your taste buds covered whether you're in the mood for lunch, dinner, or just a scrumptious dessert.

BRUSTERS Menu Prices

Food	Size	Price
Signature Waffle Cones
Waffle Cone	Small – 2 Scoops	$3.77
Waffle Cone	Regular – 3 Scoops	$4.44
Waffle Cone	Large – 4 Scoops	$5.37
Cones & Cups
Sugar Cone, Cake Cone or Cup	Small – 2 Scoops	$2.82
Sugar Cone, Cake Cone or Cup	Regular – 3 Scoops	$3.87
Sugar Cone, Cake Cone or Cup	Large – 4 Scoops	$4.91
Premium Sundaes Toppings: Peanut Butter, Hot Fudge, Pineapple, Strawberry, Butterscotch, Marshmallow, Chocolate & Caramel
Turtle Sundae		$4.95
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae		$4.95
Regular Sundae		$4.25
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae		$5.61
Banana Split		$5.61
2 Waffle Bowl Sundaes – Limited Time		$11.00
Create Your Own Blast Mix-Ins Flavors: Reese’s, Cookie Dough, Snickers, M&M’s, Butterfinger, Crunch, Heath & Oreo
Blast	Regular (16 oz.)	$4.24
Blast	Large (22 oz.)	$5.19
Milkshakes
Hand-Spun Milkshake	Regular (22 oz.)	$4.25
Hand-Spun Milkshake	Large (32 oz.)	$5.42
Ice Cold Freezes Flavors: Italian Ice, Sorbet or Sherbet
Freezes	Regular	$4.25
Very Cool Kids’ Stuff
Kids’ Dirt Sundae		$2.83
Kids’ Dino Sundae		$2.83

I love poking into the origin stories of the places I go, and Bruster's is no exception. Bruce (aka Bruster) Reed opened the first Bruster's joint in 1989, starting small but dreaming big with one simple principle - everyone deserves the deliciousness of fresh, small-batch, homemade ice cream. Bruce's incredible knack for using the freshest ingredients to whip up a variety of flavors led to the success that transformed Bruster's into a reputable franchise. Fascinatingly enough, this ice cream haven has since spread its wings, with over 200 locations, even reaching Guyana and South Korea!

If your curiosity is piqued and you want more on this ice cream star named Bruce or the Bruster's journey overall, check out their website.

Why Bruster's steals the show?

In my visits, I've found that Bruster's true magic lies in their undying commitment to freshness and quality. Every topping, all the fruit – everything's sustainably sourced. The clincher? They own their dairy, which doesn't just mean they save on costs, they also ensure the quality from cow to cone is top-notch. The lovely, rich, creamy, totally heavenly scoops of ice cream you relish are made in small batches - right there in the store. Seems like a ton of work, doesn't it? Yet, the love and dedication echo in every scrumptious bite, staying true to Bruce's vision.

Power of small-batch ice cream?

Okay, here's the thing about production scale, there are two roads - mega-scale/mass production and small-batch. Bruster's took the small-batch route, which means every time a flavor runs out, someone is behind the scenes preparing a fresh batch. This unique approach is why Bruster's never runs short of new, exciting flavors. The result is incomparable - ice cream made just hours ago is a world apart from something sitting in the freezer for weeks. After tasting Bruster's speciality, I think small-batch artisanal ice cream is their secret to fame and success.

Does Bruster's cater to dairy-free preferences?

Sure, they do! Bruster's has taken inclusivity to heart, offering a host of fabulous dairy-free choices. From refreshing sorbets to dairy-free oat-milk-based ice cream that's hearty, creamy, and oh-so-inviting. You're sure to find your fix, whether you're a vegetarian, vegan, allergic to dairy, or simply in love with oat milk. Their ice creams are just the dose of sunshine you need on a hot, sweltering day.

Is Bruster's ice cream healthy?

Okay, let's be honest. Do we hit the ice cream parlor for a health boost? Probably not. But it's great when our indulgence doesn't leave us guilt-riddled. Thankfully, Bruster's ice cream is on the healthier side with less sugar, fresh ingredients, and zero additives or preservatives. You can even tweak your treat's health quotient based on your choice of toppings and flavors. So, if you're in mood for chocolate overload (and hey, we all have those days), go ahead and dig in!

Well, to pin down a favorite from Bruster's ever-changing, wide-ranging menu is tough. While the ice cream is their raison d'etre, they've got a flavor for every season and every palate. So whether you're all about pumpkin spice in the fall, or can't resist the timeless allure of vanilla in the summer, Bruster's has got you covered. Even after 30-plus years, they never fail to keep blowing me away.